“Hi, I’m Veeno Orgavino Bonovinotte, and today we’re exploring a question that feels like it’s straight out of a dystopian novel: How much wine will you be allowed to buy if social credit systems become widespread? Let’s break it down.”
What is a Social Credit System?
“A social credit system is a method for governments and corporations to monitor everyone’s online and offline behavior, assigning them a score based on their actions. Sounds like something straight out of Black Mirror—specifically the Nosedive episode—but remember, airplanes and mobile phones were once just dreams too.
It’s similar to a financial credit score, but instead of only tracking on-time bill payments and debt, it evaluates your entire lifestyle, choices, and social interactions. Everything you own, and everything you do, will be monitored to determine your score.
These systems aim to reward ‘good’ behavior—such as paying bills on time, following laws, and engaging in government-approved activities—while punishing ‘bad’ behavior, such as missing payments, criticizing the government, or engaging in activities deemed unproductive, like spending excessive time on video games or drinking too much alcohol. Even something as simple as missing a day of work due to a hangover, leading to lower earnings and, consequently, contributing less tax to the government, could negatively impact a person’s score.
In short, a social credit system is a digital reputation system, and it could completely change the way people live, shop, and—yes—drink wine.”
Which Countries Are Using or Considering Social Credit Systems?
“Let’s take a quick look at where social credit systems are already in place, where they’re being tested, and where they’re unlikely to appear anytime soon.”
✅ Countries That Already Have Social Credit Systems:
- China – The most well-known example. People with low scores can be banned from flights, trains, and certain jobs.
- Russia – Developing a system to monitor social media activity and online behavior.
🟡 Countries Experimenting with Social Credit-Like Systems:
- European Union (EU) – Some governments track public compliance with regulations, but no official unified system exists yet.
- United Kingdom & United States – While no official government-led social credit system exists, financial institutions and online platforms in both countries have experimented with behavior-based reputation tracking. Banks, insurers, and even landlords have used social and financial data to approve or deny services.
❌ Countries Unlikely to Adopt Social Credit Systems Soon:
- Canada & Australia – Privacy concerns make widespread tracking difficult.
- Switzerland & Nordic Countries – Strong privacy laws protect citizens from extensive social monitoring.
“As technology advances, more countries could implement social credit-like systems—even if they don’t officially call it that.”
How Do Social Credit Systems Work?
“The main goal of a social credit system is to encourage government-approved behavior while discouraging what is seen as ‘harmful’ or ‘risky’ actions.
Some real-world applications of social credit systems include:
✔ Financial Rewards & Penalties – A high score can give you better access to loans, mortgages, and even discounts on services. A low score can mean higher interest rates or complete denial of credit.
✔ Travel Restrictions – Low-scoring individuals in China have been banned from flights and train travel.
✔ Employment Consequences – A bad score can stop someone from getting hired in certain industries, like finance or government work.
✔ Shopping Limitations – Governments can restrict or ban certain purchases, like alcohol or luxury goods, for low-score individuals.
So, what does this mean for wine lovers?”
Alcohol & Wine Under a Social Credit System
🛑 Why Is Alcohol Considered a Negative Factor?
“Governments already discourage alcohol consumption because of:
❌ Health concerns – Increased risk of addiction and long-term diseases.
❌ Economic burden – Alcohol-related health issues strain public healthcare systems.
❌ Social impact – Drunk driving, domestic incidents, and workplace issues.
If alcohol is classified as a negative behavior, then drinking wine could lower a person’s social credit score.”
How Wine Lovers Will Be Affected
“Wine lovers could face several restrictions under a social credit system:
1️⃣ Purchase Restrictions – If the system tracks alcohol consumption, individuals with ‘bad’ scores might be banned from buying wine entirely.
2️⃣ Higher Prices & Taxes – Governments may increase taxes on wine for people with low scores.
3️⃣ Limited Wine Tourism – Travel bans might stop wine lovers from visiting vineyards or importing wine from abroad.
4️⃣ Blocked Online Orders – Digital platforms could refuse to sell wine to individuals with low social scores.
5️⃣ Job & Reputation Risks – Employers could see frequent wine purchases as a sign of irresponsibility.
All of this means wine could soon become an elite product, available only to those with high social scores.”
What Happens to Wine Prices & Wineries?
🛒 Will Wine Prices Go Up or Down?
“Wine will likely become more expensive due to:
✔ Fewer customers – Wineries will raise prices to maintain profits.
✔ Luxury branding – Wine will be marketed as an exclusive product for high-score individuals.
✔ Increased taxes & production costs – These will be passed to consumers.
Some cheap wines might disappear altogether, and black markets could emerge—but buying illegally will come with serious risks.”
🏭 Will Wineries Survive or Go Out of Business?
“Many wineries will struggle to survive, but some will adapt:
❌ Wineries that depend on mass sales will likely shut down.
❌ Mid-sized businesses without export options may fail.
✔ Luxury wineries will survive by catering to high-score individuals.
✔ Some wineries will switch to non-alcoholic alternatives.
✔ Export-focused wineries will shift sales to countries without restrictions.”
A Counterargument: Why Some Support Social Credit Systems
“Supporters of social credit systems argue that they promote social stability, fairness, and accountability. They believe these systems create a safer, more disciplined society by discouraging harmful behaviors such as financial irresponsibility, fraud, and excessive alcohol consumption.
Proponents claim that corporate and government tracking already exists, and a formal system simply makes things more transparent and fair.
China’s model is often mentioned as an example of efficiency, where public order is maintained, and trust in institutions is strengthened. Advocates argue that a data-driven approach ensures that responsible citizens enjoy greater financial and social opportunities, rewarding law-abiding individuals while discouraging reckless behavior.”
Final Thoughts: A Future of Controlled Wine Consumption
“If social credit systems become widespread, wine drinking will no longer be a simple personal choice:
• Only individuals with high social scores will have full access to wine.
• Prices will increase, and availability will shrink.
• Wineries will either evolve or disappear.
But here’s the truth—life isn’t about the survival of the fittest or the strongest! It’s the survival of the most adaptable! If wine is restricted, wine lovers will find new ways to enjoy it.
The best solution? A complete home winemaking kit—from vine to wine. A full set of equipment allowing wine lovers to produce their favorite wine from A to Z.
Even better, wine lovers can form private winemaking teams and independent distribution groups. No government system will stop a tradition that has lasted thousands of years—just because one morning, some rich and well-connected dude woke up thinking, ‘I fancy more control over people.’”
🥂 If you enjoyed this episode, share it with a fellow wine lover! And for more great wine insights, visit Bonovinotte.com. Cheers!